Tuesday, March 24, 2009

Mauled and Devalued: "The Eustace Diamonds" Concludes

Anthony Trollope, The Eustace Diamonds: Reading Notes, Part X

A detective calls on Lizzie to tell her that her role in the disappearance of the diamonds is now known and will be revealed in open court, to which she is to be summoned as a witness (but not as a defendant). She is advised to make a clean breast of the entire story to Camperdown.

As her wedding to the egregious Sir Griffin approaches, Lucinda continues to make clear that if she is forced to the altar, the only possible outcome will be murder. Lucinda descends into madness; the marriage is called off; and Trollope (avoidant as always of extremity) hustles the bridegroom off to Japan and out of the story.

Lord Fawn uses the occasion of Lizzie's public testimony of her duplicity to finally break off the engagement. And Frank, who accompanies Lizzie to the courtroom, finds his own attraction to Lizzie waning. Frank reconciles with Lucy (who has, in the meantime, located the hitherto unknown soft heart of the Vulturess) and both of them exit the story (Frank's political career and finances no longer a narrative concern once Lizzie's spell is broken.

Lizzie retreats to Portray Castle, followed by yet another suitor -- the conniving preacher Mr. Emilius. Emilius would have had no chance at a match with someone of Lizzie's station and wealth, but her "devaluing" and "mauling" by the "fowlers" who have hunted her puts her within his reach. "She had been maimed fearfully in her late contests with the world, and was now lame and soiled and impotent." And of Emilius: "The boy with none of the equipments of the skilled sportsman can make himself master of a wounded bird. Mr. Emilius was seeking her inamoment of her weaknes, fearing that all chance os succes might be over for him should she ever again recover the full use of her wings."

Antisemitic undercurrents. The rumors that Emilius is a Jew allows Trollope to reinforce a racial line he had already drawn by having her deal with the crooked, and also Jewish, jeweler Mr. Benjamin.

The story concludes with the gossiping Lords and Ladies at the Palliser retreat at matching Priory -- reminiscent of the Gods on Olympus looking down on the lives of the Greek mortals. Trollope, however, has spoken of a world where heroes and heroines, absolute good and absolute evil no longer exist.

The moral order in "The Eustace Diamonds" is one where men and women are bound by their own fate and status. Marriage in "The Eustace Diamonds" is like a species barrier, where wealth should marry wealth, those of modest means (Frank and Lucy) flock together, and even liars wed liars (Lizzie and Emilius).


Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Sunday, March 22, 2009

Lizzie's Suitors

Anthony Trollope, The Eustace Diamonds: Reading Notes, Part IX

The putative "corsair" Lord George de Bruce Carruthers, the only one of Lizzie's suitors who knows her role in the thefts, considers whether he should force her into marrying him. "He had been careful to reduce her to a condition of despair, that she would have undoubtedly have accepted him . . ." but "she was such a mass of deceit, that he was afraid of her."

He makes his decision: "in spite of her beauty, his judgement went against her. He did not dare to share even his boat with such a dangerous fellow-passenger."

Lizzie begins maneuvering to cut the last bond between Lucy and Frank.

Without even knowing of Lizzie's complicity in the theft of the diamonds, Frank knows her to be false: "she was affected, unreal,-- and, in fact a liar in every word and look and motion." Yet "he loved her after a fashion and was prone to sit near her, and was fool enough to be flattered by her caresses."

Lizzie knows the truth of her value vis-a-vis Lucy. "Lucy could hold her ground because she was real. You may knock about a diamond and not even scratch it; whereas paste in rough usage betrays itself. Lizzie, with all her self-assuring protestations, knew that she was paste, and knew that Lucy was real stone."

Lucinda Roanoke tries everything she can to shake her irascible suitor Sir Griffin Trewitt: "he knows that I detest him, and tee he goes on with it. I have told him a score of times, but nothing will make him give it up. It is not that he loves me, but he thinks that that will be his triumph." With a "ghastly smile," she suggests to Lizzie that the only hope is that either she or Sir Griffin murders the other.

The Eustace family, including Camperdown, begins to exert pressure on Lord Fawn to honor his commitment to Lizzie, concluding "it would be a good thing to get the widow married and placed under some decent control."

Fawn writes Lizzie a letter expressing his dislike for the idea of marrying her but says he will honor his vow if she so demands.


Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Diamonds and Farthings

Anthony Trollope, The Eustace Diamonds: Reading Notes, Part VIII

Diamonds truly stolen in robbery at Mrs. Carbuncle's residence, in which Lizzie's maid Patience Crabstick is implicated.

Woven with story of diamonds is droll account of Plantagenet Palliser's titanic struggle to pass a bill in Parliament for the five farthing penny -- to move British coinage to a decimal system.

Glencora takes Lizzie's part and helps engineer social pressure on Lord Fawn to make good his commitment.

Wisdom from the thief Billie Cann: "pleasures should never be made necessities."

Billy Cann opines to Detective Gager on the police profession: "You guess. You're always a-guessing. And because you know how to guess, they pays you for guessing. But guessing ain't knowing."

The highly practical (and vulgar) Mrs. Hittaway explains to her mother Lady Fawn that her beliefs in virtue, constancy, and honesty are "antedeluvian."

Mrs. Hittaway arranges for the groundskeeper at Portray Castle to testify to Lord Fawn of Lizzie's indiscretions with Frank. But Fawn cannot bear to ask the questions required to extract the story. "He was weak and foolish and, in many respects, ignorant, -- but he was a gentleman.

Deserted by Frank, the "good as gold" Lucy looks in the mirror to view her plain clothes and admits she has been "utterly ignorant of her own value." Lucy realizes her love for Frank has been a "luxury."

Lizzie's great skills as an actress: " In the ordinary scenes of ordinary life she could not acquit herself well. There was no reality about her, and the want of it was strangely plain to most unobservant eyes. But give her a part to play that required exaggerated strong action, and she hardly ever failed."

In her confrontation with Fawn, Lizzie boldly invokes the interest in her case of the Duke of Omnium. Fawn reflects on this: "he knew that the Duke of Omnium was a worn-out old debauchee, with one foot in the grave, who was looked after by two or three women who were only anxious that he should not disgrace himself by some absurdity before he dies. Nevertheless, the Duke of Omnium, or the Duke's name, was a power in the nation."

Ironically, the loss of the diamonds has been a boon to Lizzie's fortunes and status. Learning that Patience Crabstick has been apprehended, Lizzie again worries that her duplicity will be revealed.
Frank confesses his insolvency to the sympathetic Mrs. Carbuncle: "the fact is I live in that detestable no-man's land between respectability and insolvency, which has none of the pleasures of either . . . I have all the recklessness, but none of the carelessness, of the hopelessly insolvent man."

Lizzie contemplates the renewal of her engagement to Lord Fawn with an incredulous Frank: "A woman can marry without consulting her heart. Women do so every day. The man is a Lord, and has a position."

Frank defends Lucy to Lizzie as "perfect." To which Lizzie responds acidly "can you marry this perfection without a sixpence?"



Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Saturday, March 21, 2009

Lizzieites and Anti-Lizzieites

Anthony Trollope, The Eustace Diamonds: Reading Notes, Part VII

The iron box for the diamonds stolen by professional thieves at a railway inn while Lizzie sleeps. In reality, the diamonds are safe beneath Lizzie's pillow, but she instinctively allows the police to believe the theft was successful.

Lizzie maintains her falsehood with Frank, whom she enlists in advising her how to deal with the "theft."

Neglected by her putative betrothed, Lucy Morris is outwardly confident but "there grew at her heart a little weed of care, which from week to week spread its noxious, heavy-scented leaves, and robbed her of her joyousness."

Lucy's dreary life with the Vultureress has few duties. Lady Linlithgow "simply chose to have some one sitting with her to whom she could speak and make little cross-grained, sarcastic, and ill-natured remarks."

Society divides into "Lizzieites and Anti-Lizzieites," with the Conservatives, led by Frank Greystock, holding Lizzie as an innocent victim and mistreated and the Liberals defending Lord Fawn and finding much to suspect in the robbery.

At a gathering of the Pallisers and their circle at Matching Priory -- including the Grey's of "Can You Forgive Her?" and the Chilterns and Madame Goesler of "Phineas Finn" -- all the latest rumors of the Eustace Diamonds' fate arrive by telegraph. Uncomfortably for him, Lord Fawn is among the guests. The aged, increasingly childlike Duke of Omnium obsessed with the scandal.

Glencora archly proclaims she is "quite envious" of "that little purring cat, Lady Eustace, having been so very--very clever" finding

It "delightful to think that a woman has stolen her own property and put all the police into a state of ferment."


Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Lucinda Roanoke, the reluctant fortune hunter

Anthony Trollope, The Eustace Diamonds: Reading Notes, Part VI

Lizzie's houseguests are almost entirely comprised of fortune hunters, including the adventuress Mrs. Carbuncle, her ally Lord George de Bruce Carruthers, and her icy neice Miss Lucinda Roanoke.

Odd courtship of the impatient Sir Griffin Tewitt and Lucinda. On his second proposal, when she inquires if he is quite sure of his intentions, he sputters "I'm not a man who does things without thinking; and when I've thought, I don't want to think again."

Having accepted Sir Griffin, the reluctant fortune huntress Lucinda remarks to her aunt "I hate a good many people; but of all the people in the world I hate Sir Griffin Tewitt the worst. . . . I shall have to lie to him, -- but there shall be no lying to you, however you may wish it."

Mrs. Carbuncle on marital realities: "not that girls ever really care about men now. They've got to be married, and they make the best of it."

Lucinda accepts a kiss from Sir Griffin, though "she would sooner have leaped at the blackest, darkest, dirtiest river in the county."

And then, when Lucinda is by herself: "She burst into tears. Never before had she been this polluted. The embrace had disgusted her. And if this, the beginning of it, were so bad, how was she to drink the cup to the bitter dregs?"



Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Friday, March 20, 2009

An interrogation by the Vulturess

Anthony Trollope, The Eustace Diamonds: Reading Notes, Part V

Trollope on the expense of rising in society: "let nobody dream that he can be somebody without having to pay for that honor."

Lady Linlithgow's welcome to Lucy is a chilly one. Under questioning, Lucy describes her mirthful life among Lady Fawn and her daughters, to which the Vultureress responds: "you won't find anything to laugh at here; at least, I don't. If you want to laugh, you can laugh upstairs."

Though Lucy hopes to keep private the identity of her betrothed, Lady Linlithgow performs a remarkable crossexamination, not only extracting that information but adding to it a merciless -- and quite accurate -- assessment of the motivations at play.

Addressing his readers, Trollope defends his writing of a book with an unheroic hero such as Frank Greystock. "With whom are we to sympathize? says the reader . . . Oh my reader, when you have called the dearest of your friends round you to your hospitable table, how many heroes are there sitting at the board? . . . We cannot have heroes to dine with us. There are none. But neither are our friends villians, -- whose every aspiration is for evil."

Trollope severely disapproves of the then fashionable ponytail as "a dorsal excresence."

Tempted by Lizzie's rank, wealth, and beauty, Frank continues to postpone answering the love letters from his betrothed. "A man does not write a love letter easily when he is in doubt himself whether he does or does not mean to be a scoundrel."

Lizzie's son, the heir, makes a brief appearance -- though he is not described nor does he speak -- in order to be flaunted at the childless John Eustace (much as the diamonds were flaunted before Frank Greylock). The appearance made "the boy was done and carried away. Lizzie had played that card and had turned her trick."


Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

The "good as gold" Lucy Morris

Anthony Trollope, The Eustace Diamonds: Reading Notes, Part IV

Frank's seduction by Lizzie continues. Lizzie playfully -- but pointedly -- belittles her rival Lucy: "she is tame and quiet,-- a cat that will sleep on the rug before the fire, and you think she will never scratch."

Lucy continually spoken of as being "as good as gold," but that kind of intrinsic value has little worth in exchange, as her economic status makes her unworthy in people's eyes of marriage to a rising young man such as Frank Greystock and also unworthy to voice her opinions to those above her station, as in her contretemps with the status-obsessed Lord Fawn.

Phrase from a Tennyson poem summarizes, in phony Scots dialect, the "proper" way to pursue a mercenary marriage: "Doan't thou marry for munny, but goa where munny is."

Frank's mother hopes to derail her son's marriage to Lucy, who she blames for allowing herself to be loved: "Lucy had behaved badly in allowing herself to be loved by a man who ought to have loved money."

Frank's mother acknowledges to herself that their wealthy cousin is not "good as gold" the way Lucy is, but excuses her: "Of course, Lizzie Eustace was not just all that she should be; -- but then who is?"

Frank's mother sees signs that her son is willing to abandon his "very imprudent match" and reflects: "there was no doubt about Lucy being as good as gold; -- only that real gold, vile as it was, was the one thing Frank so much needed."

Wordlessly acceding to his mother's maneuver to delay formalizing his commitment to Lucy, Frank sends his "beloved" to live as unpaid companion to the vulturess Lady Lithlingow.

Frank returns to Lizzie at Portray Castle. Seeing a ring he was given by Lucy on his hand, she unlocks and flaunts the famous diamonds at him.

Frank: "I am so poor a man that this string of stones, which you throw about the room like a child's toy, would be the making of me."

Lucy: "Take it and be made."

Frank advises Lizzie to release Lord Fawn from his commitment. But Lizzie is revenge minded: "men have become so soft themselves, that they no longer think even of punishing those who behave badly, and they expect women to be softer and more faineant than themselves."

Lizzie, who dreams of being swept up by a Byronic corsair, on Fawn: "Is he not a poor social stick; -- a bit of half-dead wood, good to make a post of, if one wants a post?" While certainly livlier than Fawn, one could hardly consider Frank byronic.

Lizzie renews her sarcastic attack on Frank's betrothed, "that prim morsel of feminine propriety who has been clever enough to make you believe that her morality would suffice to make you happy."

Lizzie enacts a passionate declaration of love to the befuddled Frank, who is entranced by her even as he also recalls that her wealth would be useful.



Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Sunday, March 15, 2009

"Like a beautiful animal you are afraid to caress for fear it should bite"

Anthony Trollope, The Eustace Diamonds: Reading Notes, Part III

Fawn consults with Camperdown, whose word he takes as "gospel," and becomes even more disquieted: Fawn "could not unravel truth quickly, but he could grasp it when it came to him. She was certainly greedy, false, and dishonest . . . Nevertheless he was engaged to marry her!"

Adding to his misery, Fawn's married sister, Mrs. Hittaway, briefs her slow-witted brother on Lizzie's status as the greatest vixen in London.

Uneasyness of Lizzie's visit to her prospective relations: "The Fawn ladies were not good hypocrites . . . and there was a general conviction in the dovecote that an evil thing had fallen upon them."

Lucy Morris confides to Frank her sense of the kind of beauty her childhood friend has become: "she looks like a beautiful animal that you are afraid to careess for fear it should bite you; -- an animal that would be beautiful if its eyes were not so restless, and its teeth so sharp and white."

John Eustace tells Frank of his sense of what Lizzie's marriage to Fawn will bring: "Fawn will be always afraid of her, -- and won't be in the least afraid of us. We shall have to fight him, and he won't fight her."

Frank Greystock debates within himself between marrying for passion -- his love of Lucy -- and marrying for ambition. [The same decision faced by Phineas Finn when he rejects the wealthy Mdm. Gensler]

Lizzie's constitutional falseness: "True love, true friendship, true benevolence, true tenderness, were beautiful to her, -- qualities on which she could descant almost with eloquence; and therefore she was always shamming love and friendship and benevolence and tenderness. She could tell you, with words most appropriate to the subject, how horrible were all shams, and in saying so would not be altogether insincere; -- yet she knew that she herself was ever shamming, and she satisfied herself with shams."

Fawn presents an ultimatum to Lizzie that she either give up the diamonds or he will break-off their marriage. Lizzie spurns both variables, determined to hold Fawn to his promise and, of course, keep the necklace. "She walked on full of fierce courage, -- despising him, but determined that she would marry him." Fawn returns to London, leaving negotiations in his mother's hands.

Fawn lost in perplexity. Trollope speaks of "the short, straight grooves of Lord Fawn's intellect."

Lizzie begins to wear the diamonds regularly in public. At one such fete, Glencora Palliser and her friend Mdm. Max Gensler debate the prospects of the pending marriage of Fawn and Lizzie.

Frank and Lucy are engaged, but he still finds himself torn -- visaulizing the domestic bliss of his marriage to the governess but drawn to his glamorous, wealthy, and dangerous cousin Lizzie.

One of the peculiarities of "The Eustace Diamonds" that Lizzie's son by the late Sir Florian, though fairly often referred to, is never seen -- at least through the first 200 pages. On her railway trip to Scotland and her home at Portray Castle, the iron case bearing the necklace is at center stage, but the heir is never glimpsed.



Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Legal dueling and matrimonial speculation

Anthony Trollope, The Eustace Diamonds: Reading Notes, Part II

The duel begins between the Eustace family lawyer, Mr. Camperdown, and Lizzie over the possession of the diamond necklace, with Lizzie advised by her not entirely scrupulous attorneys Messrs. Mobray and Mopus.

Definition: appaneges = dependent possessions

Camperdown incensed at Lizzie's willful retention of the necklace: "£10,000 my dear John! And she is to be allowed to filch it as other widows filch china cups and a silver teaspoon or two!"

In her face-off with Camperdown, Lizzie desperately wishes sage advice, but hesitates as all those from whom she would seek it would be likely to advise her to return the diamonds -- which, of course, she is determined not to do.

The "vulturess" Lady Linlithgow comes to Lizzie on an embassy from Camperdown. Though old, she has great resilience: "she was one of those old women . . . on whom old age appears to have no debilitating effects. If the hand of Lady Lithlingow ever trembled, it trembled from anger; -- if her foot ever faltered, it faltered for effect. . . . She was as hard as an oak post, -- but then she was also as reliable."

Of Lucy's charitable but domineering employer Lady Fawn (who has forbidden her to receive visits by Frank Greylock): "Lady Fawn was a tower of strength to Lucy. But then a tower of strength may at any moment become a dungeon."

Lizzie, desperate for support, accepts Lord Fawn's proposal of marriage. Fawn, meanwhile, is in straightened circumstances and has his eyes fixed on Lizzie's income.

His proposal very much an act of "matrimonial speculation," Lord Fawn has investigated Lizzie's finances -- and appreciates her beauty -- but has no idea of her character whatsoever. "For aught he knew, she might be afflicted by every vice to which a woman can be subject. In truth, she was afflicted by so many, that the addition of all the others could hardly have made her worse than she was."

In their marital negotiations, Fawn is slow but practical and Lizzie "quick as a lizard" but ill-informed. Lizzie is shocked to hear that Fawn's lawyer is Mr. Camperdown; Fawn equally disquieted to learn that the Eustace family is threatening legal action for recovery of the diamond necklace.

To lock the discomfited Lord Fawn into the marriage, Lizzie quickly broadcasts news of the engagement throughout society.





Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Saturday, March 14, 2009

The jewel-bedecked girl: "The Eustace Diamonds" begins

Anthony Trollope, The Eustace Diamonds: Reading Notes, Part I

Trollope introduces Lizzie Greylock -- who will become Lady Eustace -- as a girl who, though her father has no particular fortune "went about everywhere with jewels on her fingers, and red gems hanging around her neck, and yellow gems pendent from her ears, and white gems shining in her black hair."

Her father's interests to his very deathbed are limited to "whist, wine, and wickedness in general." On his death, Lizzie goes to live with her horrid aunt Lady Linlithgow, who she calls, with good reason, "the old vulturess."

Lizzie cuts a deal with her father's debtors to retain her jewels until she can finalize her match with the wealthy Sir Florian Eustace.

One additional apparent appeal of Sir Florian for Lizzie is that he is dying. Sir Florian combines selfless nobility and thoughtless vice: "he was one who denied himself no pleasure, let the cost be what it might in health, pocket, or morals."

"Blear-eyed in his ways around town," Sir Florian mistakes the calculating Lizzie for the "the purest, the truest, and the noblest" of women.

Lizzie: "As she was utterly devoid of true tenderness, so she was also devoid of conscience."

Lizzie engineers her marriage to Sir Florian quickly, and he dies of his lingering infirmity less than a year later. "She had so far played her game well, and had won her stakes."

Lizzie's reptilian allure: "her figure was lithe and soft and slim and slender . .. She was almost snake-like in her rapid bendings and the almost too easy gestures of her body."

Lizzie's eyes: "blue and clear, bright as cerulian waters. They were long, large eyes -- but very dangerous. To those who knew how to read a face, there was danger plainly written in them. Poor Sir Florian had not known."

After Sir Florian's death, Lizzie gives birth to an heir and, of seemingly just as much concern to the family, makes claim to a family heirloom -- a massive diamond necklace valued at £10,000.

Lizzie's childhood friend, the governess Lucy Morris, is her opposite in both temperment and approach to life. Straightforward and accepting of her status -- she envies no one. Yet "to herself, no one was her superior." However admirable, she is, Trollope informs us, not a heroine.

The Tory temperment to see all change, even that which benefits them, as ill and feel "well-assured that all good things are gradually being brought to an end by the voice of the people."

Lizzie's cousin -- and Lucy's beloved -- Frank Graystock is a Tory M.P. not from ideology but from opportunity.

Lizzie's brother-in-law, John Eustace, hopes to induce Frank to marry his brother's troublesome widow -- "she is making herself queer . . . she doesn't know know what she ought to be at, and what she ought not. You could tell her."


Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Sunday, February 15, 2009

Gulliver travels homeward

Jonathan Swift, Gulliver's Travels: Reading Notes, Part V (final)

The totalitarian streak in the Houyhnhnm society becomes clearer and clearer.

One aspect of the "natural" society of the Houyhnhnm is apparently racial stratification: "He made me observe that, among the Houyhnhnms, the white, the sorrel, and the iron-grey, were not so exactly shaped as the bay, the dapple-grey, and the black; nor born with equal talents of the mind, or a capacity to improve them; and therefore continued always in the condition of servants, without ever aspiring to match out of their own race, which in that country would be reckoned monstrous and unnatural."

From his dialogue with the master horse, Gulliver comes to see the superiority of the "rational" -- and unlettered -- Houyhnhnm, with their "general disposition to all virtues" compared with his own debased race and society.

Clearly said virtues do not include liberty: the Houyhnhnm practice birth control (through the social regulation of copulation) and also eugenics in the form of careful breeding so as "to preserve the race from degenerating." There is no romance: marriages are arranged. Nor is there love or pride of parents for their offspring, as the colts and foals are brought up collectively with the young distributed as necessary to maintain social equity.

The master horse reports to Gulliver on a debate at the Houyhnhnm grand council on whether to forceably annihilate the troublesome and inferior Yahoo population that has "infested" the nation. Finding that an extreme measure, the master horse himself counterproposes that the Houyhnhnm adopt a practice Gulliver described to him and simply castrate the Yahoo males.

At the grand council, it is further revealed that the first Yahoo came to Houyhnhnm after a shipwreck -- from their physiognomies, Gulliver believes they may be of English descent -- and propagated without control from then.

Yahoos are scapegoats for all ills of Houyhnhnm society. "The Houyhnhnm have no word in their language to express anything that is evil, except what they borrow from the deformaties and ill qualities of the Yahoos. Thus they denote the folly of a servant, an omission of a child, a stone that cuts their feet, a continuance of foul or unseasonable weather, and the like, by adding to each the epithet of Yahoo."

Gulliver describes his great contentment in the pre-modern Houyhnhnm society. In a first hint of collaborationism, his list of household arrangements mentions without note that the replacement leather for his shoes comes from Yahoo skin.

Gulliver becomes an assimilationist. He looks with horror on his reflection when he sees it in a pond and begins imitating the gait, gesture, and diction of his noble hosts.

The master horse reluctantly discloses to Gulliver that at the same great council at which the eradication of the Yahoos was discussed, it was "exhorted" that Gulliver should be expelled from the country.

Despondently, Gulliver begins building a canoe from the scrubby wood available in that land, "covering it with the skins of Yahoos" with a sail "composed of the skins of the same animals" sealed with pitch from "Yahoo's tallow" and, when completed, hauled down to the sea by Yahoo labor.

The grateful Gulliver bids farewell to his benevolent master: "as I was going to prostrate myself to kiss his hoof, he did me the honor to raise it gently to my mouth. I am not ignorant how much I have been censured for mentioning this last particular."

When Gulliver is discovered by others of his kind, Portuguese sailors, he is horrified to hear such "Yahoos" speak ("as monstrous as if a cow or dog would speak in England"). For their part, they laugh at the neighing pronounciation Gulliver has adopted.

Returning to England, Gulliver is repelled by his Yahoo wife and children ("the sight of them filled me with hatred, disgust, and contempt"), prefering the company of two young stone horses with whom he converses at least four hours each day.

Writing from a distance of several years from exile in England from his beloved Houyhnhnm, Gulliver is still not reconciled to Yahoo-kind, though he can now countenance all the vile sins he sees around him with one exception -- human pride.




Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Gulliver in the land of Houyhnhnms and Yahoos

Jonathan Swift, Gulliver's Travels: Reading Notes, Part IV

"Travels into Several Remote Nations of the World: Part 4, A Voyage to the Houyhnhnms"

Gulliver's ship taken over by mutineers and he is set adrift near an unknown island, likely near Madagascar. He has with him the kinds of trading goods one employs in dealing with "savages" -- knives, bracelets of false pearl, small mirrors, and beads.

He encounters the Yahoos and is disgusted by their physical appearance, even as his description makes it apparent they are humanoid.

He next finds the Houyhnhnms, civilized horses, who are astounded to be confronted by a Yahoo with clothing -- "whereof they had no conception" -- and the faculty of speech.

The Yahoos are meat eaters; the Houyhnhnms vegetarians. Of necessity, Gulliver adopts a vegetarian, salt-free diet and "cannot but observe, that I never had one hour's sickness while I stayed in this island."

A dinner guest arrives at the home of the "master horse" in a sleigh drawn by four Yahoos.

Upon closer inspection, Gulliver realizes Yahoos are "savage" humans, but he refuses to see them as of his kind.

Gulliver avoids being seen without clothes in order to "distinguish myself as much as possible from the cursed race of Yahoos."

He relates that "the word Houyhnhnm in their tongue signifies a horse, and in its eytmology, the perfection of nature." In keeping with that perfection, the Houyhnhnm have no shame of "any parts of their bodies" and their language has no word for lying or, thus, for doubt or disbelief.

Gulliver describes to the master horse the life of servitude of his kind in England -- and of methods of training including bridles, saddles, whips, and spurs and the castrating of working horses to make them more docile -- drawing similar outrage as to when he told the Brobdingnag King about European munitions.

As Gulliver describes the variety of human behavior to the master horse -- lawsuits, drunkenness, whoring, gaming, sodomy, treason, murder, theft, poisoning, coining false money, rape, etc. etc. -- he needs to stop to explain every one of those vices as none exist among the Houyhnhnm. "This labor took up several days conversation before he was able to comprehend me."

Gulliver then embarks on an encyclopedic yet matter-of-fact enumeration of all the reasons why the princes of his own land go to war and a brief overview of the carnage of battle. To which the master horse responds that "whoever understood the nature of Yahoos might easily believe it possible for so vile an animal to be capable of every action I had named, if their strength and cunning equalled their malice."

Then, Gulliver describes the profession of law, again unknown to the Houyhnhnm: "I said there was a society of men among us, bred up from their youth in the art of proving by words multiplied for the purpose, that white is black, and black white, according as they are paid. To this society all the rest of the people are slaves."

The use of money, the extremes of Yahoo wealth and poverty, and global trade are expoused. England, Gulliver explains, exports the food that could easily feed its masses: "sending away the greatest part of our necessary things to other countries, from whence in return we brought the materials of diseases, folly, and vice, to spread among ourselves. Hence it follows of necessity that vast numbers of our people are compelled to seek their livelihood by begging, robbing, stealing, cheating, pimping, foreswearing, flattering, suborning, forging, gaming, lying, fawning, hectoring, voting, scribbling, star-gazing, poisoning, whoring, canting, libelling, freethinking, and the like occupations; every one of which terms, I was at much pains to make him understand."

Gulliver then describes the diseases caused by the Yahoo's tendencies toward excess and then the medical profession with its love of purgatives and emetics. He further relates: "Besides real diseases we are subject to many that are only imaginary, for which physicians have invented imaginary cures."

The master horse contemplates the odiousness of the human form compared to other creatures and concludes it not unwise that those of Gulliver's homeland choose to cover their bodies "and by that invention conceal many of our own deformaties from each other."

Gulliver takes trips to observe the Yahoos in the wild and more and more sees the similarities in his species behavior in its natural state with that of civilized Europe. These field trips culminate in his nearly being raped by an 11 year old Yahoo girl when he his nakedness is revealed while swimming in a pond.

Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Gulliver among the Laputans and nearby states

Jonathan Swift, Gulliver's Travels: Reading Notes, Part III

"Travels into Several Remote Nations of the World: Part 3, A Voyage to Laputa, Balnibarbi, Glubbdubdrib, Luggnagg, and Japan."

Laputa a floating island that contains the royal court, hovering over the vassal lands below.

The entire principality impoverished by abstract science -- mathematics is the only topic of learning, astronomy the only subject of court discourse, and music the only art form. Those in the floating city detached from the reality below; those below live in rags, victims of a public policy focused on future projections -- the scientists are called "projectors" -- rather than present.

Laputans live with their heads tilted so that one eye is always looking at the stars. They are so lost in their own thoughts that servants are equipped with small baldders with which they gently hit their masters' eyes, ears, and mouths in order to remind them to look at, listen, and respond to their interlocutors.

Gulliver's tailor in Laputa measures him, inaccurately, with a sextant. Not surprisingly, then, ill-fitting clothes are common in Laputa.

Dining in Laputa: "shoulder of mutton cut into an equilateral triangle, a piece of beef into a rhomboid, and a pudding into a cycloid ... the servents cut our bread into cones, cylinders, parallelograms, and several other mathematical figures."

Among the experiments at the Academy of Science in the city below the floating island are projects to extract sun-beams from cucumbers; to return human excrement to its original food matter; to build houses from the roof downward to the foundation; and to prevent the growth of wool on young lambs in order to create a race of naked sheep.

The Academy also houses a primitive computer -- a twenty foot wooden frame with bits of wood strung along wires on which are written all the words of their language. By pulling all the wires simultaneously, the words are shuffled into a new order, with the sentences thus created scrutinized for meaning. In time, of course, all possible sentences and meanings would of necessity occur along the wires of the frame. The scientist ("projector") proposes to hasten his work by constructing fifty such frames (a network!)across the kingdom.

Gulliver finds equally dubious ideas under consideration at the Academy of Political Science, including proposals that princes choose ministers based on merit, make policy decisions based on the public good, "and many other wild impossible chimeras that never entered before into the heart of man to conceive."

Another Laputan political scientist proposes that the heads of political opponents be surgically opened and hemispheres of their brains swapped so that each legislator holds both perspectives.

Leaving Laputan possessions, Gulliver visits Glubbdubdrib, a land of the dead where he interviews great personages of the past and discovers the falsity of official histories and the prevalence of corruption, vice, cowardice, ingratitude, and dishonesty among the powerful and noble.

He next ventures to Luggnagg, where a small number of individuals each generation are born into immortality -- a miserable condition, Gulliver discovers, as those "struldbrug" experience life as a continuing process of decrepitude; an eternity of enfeeblement.

He returns via Japan which, interestingly, is in commerce with both the mythic lands of Gulliver's most recent voyages and with Europe.



Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Saturday, February 14, 2009

Gulliver in Brobdingnag

Jonathan Swift, Gulliver's Travels: Reading Notes, Part II

"Travels into Several Remote Nations of the World: Part 2, A Voyage to Brobdingnag."

Brobdingnag situated by Gulliver and by map in first edition as a peninsula on west coast of North America, well above known California settlements of Monterrey and Mendocino (and thus, it is fun to imagine, quite possibly the Long Beach peninsula of Washington State).

Encountering giant Brobdingnags, Gulliver muses on changes in status brought by size and power alone: "in this terrible agitation of mind, I could not forebear thinking of Lilliput . . . Where I was able to draw an Imperial Fleet in my hand, and perform those other actions which will be recorded forever in the chronicles of that empire, while posterity shall hardly believe them, although attested by millions. I reflected what a mortification it must prove to me to appear as inconsiderable in this nation as one single Lillupitian would be among us."

From living myth in Lilliput to insignificant morsel, Gulliver's initial status in Brobdingnag that of an animal; the farmer plucks him from amid the furrows and examines him as he would a weasel. "What could I expect but to be a morsel in the mouth of the first among these enormous barbarians that should happen to seize me."

Immediate reaction of farm family is to treat Gulliver like an animal or plaything despite his human characteristics and behavior -- the mother shrieks as if he were a toad or shrew; the son dangles and plucks at him the way all children are mischievous "toward sparrows, rabbits, young kittens, and puppy dogs"; and the infant sticks the tiny Gulliver in her mouth.

It is the young daughter who sees Gulliver's personhood (though she seems to enjoy dressing and undressing him as if he were a doll) and he comes into her care until the plan arises to exhibit him at the town fair for money arises. The daughter realizes Gulliver is to be taken away from her just as "last year, when they pretended to give her a lamb, and yet, as soon as it was day, sold it to a butcher."

Gulliver exhibited by the farmer far-and-wide, performing English mannerisms such as flourishing his sword and doffing his hat for the eager crowds. Resonance here with how natives were brought back to Europe by explorers as curiosities.

Gulliver's name in Brobdingnag is Grildrig (Little Man).

Gulliver sold to Queen, who finds him appealing. King at first cannot decide if he is an animal or clever clockwork. He becomes a part of the royal household, quickly earning the resentment of the Royal Dwarf, now supplanted as a curiosity.

Gulliver's size allows him to see how disguisting household flies are with their feces and secretions. He is horrified to see Queen devour entire birds, bones and all, though he devoured Lilliput's tiny viands in similar fashion.

Magnitude of Brobdingnagians makes apparent the imperfections of their flesh -- mottled, pitted -- just as miniature Lilliputians seemed physically perfect and charming.

Equivalent to looking through a microscope, Gulliver sees true nature of the world: "the most hateful sight of all was the lice crawling on their clothes. I could see distinctly the limbs of these vermin with my naked eye, much better than a European loise through a microscope, and their snouts with which they rooted like swine."

"Gulliver's Travels" as an ocular adventure. His great size in Lilliput allows him to see the pettiness of human society; his tiny size in Brobdingnag reveals the grossness and beastliness of human existence.

More disgust, this time ofalcatory: "The Maids of Honor . . . would often strip me naked from top to toe, and lay me at full length in their bosoms; wherewith I was much disgusted; because to say the truth a very offensive odor came from their skins."

Pre-Darwinian moment: a monkey at the Castle mistakes Gulliver for "a young one of his own species," runs off with him and rocks him like a baby while feeding him from his own provender.

The king interrogates Gulliver on the affairs of England. Gulliver provides a panygeric, but after close questioning the King states: "from the answers I have with much pains wringed and extorted from you, I cannot but conclude the bulk of your natives to be the most pernicious race of little odious vermin that nature ever suffered to crawl upon the surface of the earth."

Attempting again to assert superiority of English society, Gulliver describes his world's munitions and offers to construct such devices for Brobdingnag. The king is horrified that such murderous, inhuman machines could be viewed as a sign of a nation's greatness and finds Gulliver's offer repellent, calling him an "impotent and groveling insect."

Regarding such denunciation, Gulliver opines to his reader that the King has "narrow principles and short views" in his rejection of a technology which would make him "absolute master of the lives, the liberties, and the fortunes of his people."

The Brobdingnag King's political philosophy: "he gave it for his opinion that whoever could make two ears of corn or two blades of grass grow upon a spot of ground where only one grew before, would deserve better of mankind, and do more essential service to his country than the whole race of politicians put together."

Gulliver reads a work of Brobdingnag philosophy that suggests humans must have once been of greater stature. A devolution from Brobdingnagians (x10)through Europeans to Lilliputians (-10)?



Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Gulliver in Lilliput

Jonathan Swift, Gulliver's Travels: Reading Notes, Part I

True title of this first volume of work now popularly known as "Gulliver's Travels" is: "Travels into Several Remote Nations of the World: Part 1, A Voyage to Lilliput."

Lilliput situated by Gulliver and by map in first edition as near Tasmania (Van Diemen's Land).

Gulliver a common man brought into Court. The "foreigness" of his Lilliputian sojurn as much a matter of contact with Princes and ministers as experience of the 1/10th scale world.

Indication of gulf in manners between the sailor Gulliver and his noble patrons in his act of successfully extinguishing an uncontrollable blaze in the royal palace by urinating on it.

Gulliver's name among the Lilliputians is Quinbus Flestrin (the Man Mountain).

Lilliput on first glance seems harmonious, but is soon revealed as riven by faction -- the high-heeled Tramecksans vs. the low-heeled Slamecksans -- and, more bitterly still, by the heresy of those who eat soft-boiled eggs from the larger end (Big-endians) rather than the small-end.

Lillupitians and Blefuscuans separated by language and by sect (Small-endian Lilliputians vs. Big-endian Blefuscuans). As with Europeans prior to Age of Discovery, scepticism among learned men that other lands and peoples can exist despite overwhelming evidence, in Gulliver's testimony that they must.

Though Gulliver rises to nobility by aiding the Lillupitian Emperor in foiling the invasion plans of the Blefuscuans -- in gratitude, he is made a "Nardac" -- he earns the enmity of that monarch by not participating in the proposed eradication of the Big-endian heretics. From which, Gulliver draws lesson that: "Of so little weight are the greatest services to princes, when put into balance with a refusal to gratify their passions."

Matter of factness of ministerial accusations and factional plots against Gulliver, from secret poisonings to legal sentences of blinding or starvation. Ministerial denunciations of Gulliver are military (threat of his strength), economic (burden of his feeding), political (suspicion he is a crypto- Big-endian) and moral (his act of urinating on the Royal residence, even if to save it from the flames).

Gulliver's experience as a courtier in Lilliput of the vagaries of princely favor causes him to resolve "never more to put any confidence in Princes or Ministers, where I could possibly avoid it."

Gulliver takes refuge in Blefuscu and arranges for his departure in the salvaged longboat. He nurtures a small herd of Lillupitian livestock as testmony of his adventure, though one of the sheep is eaten by a rat on the English ship that rescues him.



Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Sunday, February 08, 2009

"Micah Clarke" Concludes: Honorable mercenaries and thieves

Arthur Conan Doyle, Micah Clarke: Reading Notes, Part Ten

Just as Micah saved Decimus from the Dutch slaver at the book's opening, so Decimus appears on the scene to free Micah from his bondage and to set him up as a soldier-of-fortune in Europe -- welcoming him to the brotherhood of "the old and honorable guild." Thus, Decimus becomes yet another of Micah's several father figures.

Decimus further establishes the honorable highwayman Hector Marot on board the slaver with the plan that he will incite a mutiny among the Barbadoes-bound enslaved Puritans.

"If I were captain," chortles Decimus, "I would rather have the Devil himself, horns, hoof, and tail, for my first mate than have that man aboard my ship."

For his own part, Decimus has blackmailed Beaufort into arranging for him a commission to fight Indians in the New England colony of Virginia.

Micah relates that Decimus "did so out-ambush their ambushes and out-trick their most cunning warriors," that the Indians gave him a name meaning "the long-legged wily one with the eye of a rat."

At night, Micah still has visions of Decimus' face with its "shifting, blinky eyes turned toward me in his sidelong fashion."

He was, Micah concludes, "a bad man in many ways . . . cunning and wily, with little scruple of conscience; and yet so strange a thing is human nature, and so difficult it is to control our feelings, that my heart warms when I think of him, and that fifty years have increased rather than weakened the kindliness which I bear to him."



Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

The Taunton Assizes: The work of legal slaughter

Arthur Conan Doyle, Micah Clarke: Reading Notes, Part Nine

Micah betrayed and arrested. He is warned by soldiers that his fate will be determined by civil rather than military law. "They have a lawyer coming from London whose wig is more to be feared than our helmets. He will slay more men in a day than a troop in a ten mile chase."

The Taunton Assizes: trials merely formalities where prisoners were "hauled before a judge and insulted before being dragged to the gibbet."

Chief Justice Jeffreys: "he raved like a demoniac and his black eyes shown with a vivid vindictive brightness that was scarce human. The jury shrank from him as from a venomous thing when be turned his baleful glance upon them. At times, as I have been told, his sternness have way to an even more terrible merriment, and he would lean back in his seat of justice until the tears hopped down upon his ermine. Nearly a hundred were either executed or condemned to death on that opening day."

The streets of Taunton lined with the rotting corpses of rebels. Micah sees "the limbs of former companions dangling in the wind, and their heads grinning at us from the tops of poles and pikes."

Use of kettledrums at military executions "to drown out any last words that would fall from the sufferers and bear fruit in the breasts of those who heard them."

Rather than facing execution, Micah and fifty other prisoners sold as slaves for overseas Plantations as James' way of rewarding his loyalists.

Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

The Battle of Sedgemoor: The work of military slaughter

Arthur Conan Doyle, Micah Clarke: Reading Notes, Part Eight

Eve of the battle of Sedgemoor: "nothing less than a miracle could preserve us from defeat, and most of us were of the opinion that the days of miracles were past. Others, however, thought otherwise. I believe that many of our Puritans, had they seen the heavens open that night, and the armies of the Seraphim and the Cherubim descending to our aid, would have looked upon it as by no means a wonderful or unexpected occurance."

"The whole town was loud with the preaching. Every troop or company had its own chosen orator and sometimes more than one . . . Men were drunk with religion as with wine. Their faces were flush, their speech thick, their gestures wild."

The somber Micah: "win who will, English blood must soak the soil of England this night."

The devil-may-care Sir Gervas: "The more room for those who are left."

Micah: "The chances are that few of us will ever see tomorrow's sun-rise."

Sir Gervas: "I have no great curiosity to see it. It will be much as yesterday's."

When it becomes apparent that the battle is lost, Monmouth rides off with his entourage: "There, far away, showing up against the dark peat-colored soil, rode a gaily-dressed cavalier, followed by a knot of attendants, galloping as fast as his horse would carry him from the field of battle. There was no mistaking the fugitive. It was the recreant Monmouth."

Sir Gervas, who dies bravely among his men, initially mistaken by Royal troops for Monmouth. Clear that Monmouth can only act the part of nobility and bravery.

Of the carnage, Micah reflects: "men must either give up war or they must confess that the words of the Redeemer are too lofty for them, and that there is no longer any use in pretending that His teaching can be reduced to practice."

While escaping after the rout, Micah prevents Decimus from finishing off a helpless Royal officer, earning the dangerous enmity of the soldier-of-fortune.



Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

Fickle leaders, barbarous soldiers, and noble highwaymen

Arthur Conan Doyle, Micah Clarke: Reading Notes, Part Seven


As the military tide turns against him, Monmouth's failings become manifest: "Swinging from the heights of confidence to the depths of despair, choosing his future council of state one day and proposing to fly from his army the next, he appeared from the start to be possessed by the very spirit of fickleness."

The vain but generous and brave dandy Sir Gervas is inspired by his sojurn among the "clodhoppers" and rural tradesmen: "Truth to tell, I have lived more and learned more during these few weeks that we have been sliding about in the rain with our ragged lads than ever I did [at court]. It is a sorry thing for a man's mind to have nothing higher to dwell upon than the turning of a compliment or the dancing of a corranto."

Royal troops portrayed as given to plunder and torture, the latter a set of skills learned in service in North Africa and Russia -- a byproduct of Imperial activity and, so, not native to England. Smugglers and highwaymen, such as Captain Murgatroyd and Hector Marrot, are possessed with a sense of English due process and fair play.

The highwayman Hector Marrot on his trade: "there is no road that is not familiar to me, nor as much as a break of the hedge I could not find in blackest midnight. It is my calling. But the trade is not what it was [with the introduction of paper bills of exchange]. If I had a son, I would not bring him up in it."

Marrot's story of retired highwayman who becomes a great landlord and sits in judgement of others -- "condemning some poor devil for stealing a dozen eggs" -- reminiscent of Defoe.

Marrot characterizes thieving as "hunting, save that your quarry may at any time turn round upon you, and become in turn the hunter. It is, as you say, a dangerous game, but two can play at it, and each has an equal chance."


Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry

"The voices of preachers rose up like the drone of insects"

Arthur Conan Doyle, Micah Clarke: Reading Notes, Part Six

Beaufort publicly imprisons and condemns Micah as a traitor but then privately and secretly releases him.

During Micah's public condemnation by Beaufort -- before his covert release by the same noble -- debate over whether he should be tortured to reveal details of Monmouth's forces. Again recalling Scott's "Old Mortality" mention is made of placing "a lighted match between the fingers."

When Micah reports on his experiences and Beaufort's divided loyalty, Monmouth muses: "He would fain stand upon both sides of the hedge at once . . . Such a man is very like to find himself on neither side, but in the very heart of the briars."

In the meantime, Monmouth's camp has become religiously divided: "the voices of preachers rose up like the drone of insects" with "every wagon or barrel or chance provision case converted into a pulpit, each with its own orator and little knot of eager hearkeners."

As the courtiers and professional military men worry about the lack or ordinance, the zealots rail that the Lord will provide as he did at the walls of Jerico.

Decimus pleased at this outbreak of dissention and fervor: "the leaven is working. Something will come of all this ferment."

Monmouth's sympathy with these rough-clad zealots a dubious one. When military events begin to turn against him, he is described as "moodily tapping his jeweled riding-whip against his high boots."

Then, the "leaven" truly begins to boil over as one of the extreme sectarian preachers urges his followers to (Taliban like) demolish Wells cathedral in order to regain God's favor. Cathedrals "altars of Baal . . . built for man-worship rather than God-worship . . . the old dish of Popery served under a new cover."

The sectaries literally commence to tear-down religion. Shouts the Cathedral verger: "they have pulled down Saint Peter and will have Paul down too unless help comes. There will not be an Apostle left."

Soon the zealots are joined by looters and drunken rioters taking advantage of the disarray and destruction. Micah, Sexton et al. try to calm the affray and soon "a Civil War within a Civil War breaks out."

Micah, speaking now as an old man, concludes that he never saw a more brutal battle than the religious fight within the cathedral.


Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry